If you have multiple ip addresses on your Windows Server, Windows always use nearest ip adress to gateway. So if you need to change it, you should remove all ip addresses and add it via Netsh.

netsh interface ip add address "Local Area Connection" 10.10.10.2 255.255.255.0 skipassource=true

Skipassource means Windows won’t use this ip address for outgoing communication unless explicitly set for use by outgoing packets.